| Platinum | Jersey Mike's Subs |
| Gold | Lattanzio Sandwiches |
| Silver | V & S Sandwich Shop |
| Bronze | Tom Cat Cafe |
| Top Pick | Esposito's Restaurant & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Frank's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Margherita Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Screpesi's Sandwich Shop |
| Top Pick | Sophia's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria |