| Platinum | Coastal Grille |
| Gold | Giannotti's Country Manor |
| Silver | Go Fish Seafood |
| Bronze | Suburban Tavern & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Bixler's Lodge |
| Top Pick | Crab Crazy |
| Top Pick | Exeter Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Gettin Crabby At The Crab Barn |
| Top Pick | Judy's On Cherry |
| Top Pick | Salute Ristorante Italiano |