| Platinum | Black Sheep Tavern |
| Gold | Louie's Kitchen and Bar |
| Silver | Annamarie’s on Main |
| Silver | Austin's Restaurant & Bar |
| Silver | JD's Steaks |
| Bronze | Doc and Bubba's |
| Bronze | UpDog Hot Dogs |
| Top Pick | Exeter Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mama's Pizza and Grill |
| Top Pick | Screpesi's Sandwich Shop |
| Top Pick | Trish's Specialty Cheese Cakes |