| Platinum | Sprechers Meat Market |
| Gold | Shady Maple |
| Silver | Dietrich Country Meats |
| Bronze | Boyer's Food Markets |
| Top Pick | Adelphia Seafood |
| Top Pick | Andre's Country Market |
| Top Pick | Blue Mountain Meats |
| Top Pick | Christman's Meats & Deli |
| Top Pick | Dundore & Heister |
| Top Pick | Sammy's Superior Meats |