| Platinum | Nonno Alby's Brick Oven Pizza |
| Gold | The Spartaco |
| Silver | Mom Chaffe's Cellarette |
| Bronze | Mimmo's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | GNA Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Nino's |
| Top Pick | Paolo's Pizza Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Salvatore's |
| Top Pick | Sebastiano's Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Vincenzo's Restaurant Italiano |